News · BFSI
India's insurance regulator has penalised Star Health and Allied Insurance Company Ltd ₹2 crore for improper repudiation of COVID-19 hospitalisation claims and deductions not supported by policy terms.
✦ AI SUMMARY 30-second read
- IRDAI imposed two penalties of ₹1 crore each on Star Health in its final order dated 20 November 2026, following a general inspection conducted between 31 January and 11 February 2022.
- The first penalty relates to rejection of COVID-19 hospitalisation claims on the grounds that patients could have been treated at home; the second concerns deductions without adequate policy basis and poor claim communication.
- Star Health must pay the ₹2 crore penalty by debiting its shareholders' account within 45 days, place the order before its board, and file an Action Taken Report within 90 days.
Why it matters: The order reinforces that insurers must settle claims strictly on policy contract terms, not external guidelines or unverified rate schedules.
This summary was generated by AI. Editors may review and update it.
The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) has penalised Star Health and Allied Insurance Company Ltd a total of ₹2 crore for violations related to COVID-19 claim repudiations, deductions not grounded in policy terms, and inadequate communication with policyholders about the reasons for claim decisions.
The final order, dated 20 November 2026, imposes two separate penalties of ₹1 crore each. IRDAI also issued warnings, cautions and directions covering other lapses identified during its review.
The action stems from a general inspection carried out between 31 January and 11 February 2022. A show-cause notice was issued in December 2024, the insurer's response was considered, and a personal hearing was held in June 2025 before the order was passed.
COVID-19 claim repudiations
A central finding in the order is that Star Health rejected COVID-19 hospitalisation claims on the basis that the patients concerned could have been treated at home rather than admitted to hospital. The insurer cited guidelines from institutions including the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS), the World Health Organisation (WHO), the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) and the Union Ministry of Health and Family Welfare to support this position. It also pointed to the extraordinary pressure on healthcare facilities during the pandemic and alleged overcharging by hospitals.
IRDAI examined Star Health's family health optima policy and found that it covered hospitalisation expenses incurred on the advice of a qualified physician, medical specialist, medical practitioner or surgeon. The regulator concluded that the insurer could not use external institutional guidelines to override coverage that the policy itself provided.
IRDAI held that Star Health had violated Regulation 27(v) of the IRDAI (Health Insurance) Regulations, 2016, and imposed a ₹1 crore penalty under Section 102 of the Insurance Act, 1938.
Arbitrary deductions and poor claim communication
The second ₹1 crore penalty addresses deductions that the regulator found were not adequately supported by specific policy clauses. During inspection, IRDAI reviewed Bill Assessment Sheets describing deductions as 'member payment vis a vis terms and conditions of the policy issued' and asked Star Health to identify the precise clauses permitting such deductions. The insurer did not provide the information in the manner sought.
The regulator also found that settlement and repudiation communications sent to policyholders did not clearly identify the policy conditions relied upon, as required under Regulation 33(d)(iv) of the Health Insurance Regulations. The insurer produced documents showing final amounts settled but could not establish that these communications had been sent through its own system as claimed.
IRDAI specifically objected to Star Health using General Insurance Council (GIC) rates to reduce or deny COVID-19 claims without linking those rates to relevant policy provisions. The regulator noted that the insurer had subsequently reconsidered some claims and paid additional amounts after concerns were raised, which it said suggested the original decisions may not have been consistent with policy terms.
Deductions under 'reasonable and customary charges' were found to be particularly high in FY2021-22. Star Health attributed this to pandemic-era hospital overbilling but did not substantiate the deductions through specific policy clauses or item-wise evidence. When the insurer later submitted sample cases with detailed break-ups, IRDAI found these differed materially from the cases identified during inspection.
Other directions and dropped charge
IRDAI warned Star Health for failing to ensure that agreed discounts with network hospitals were reflected in final hospital bills before calculating policyholders' liability, as required under Regulation 20(9) of the IRDAI (Third Party Administrators–Health Services) Regulations, 2016. The regulator directed the insurer to ensure that final settlement letters clearly identify allowed, disallowed, non-payable and discounted items.
The insurer was also cautioned for grievance communications that omitted the name and address of the Insurance Ombudsman having jurisdiction, and for collecting renewal premiums more than 90 days in advance due to a technical system error. Star Health said a two-step validation mechanism was introduced in February 2023 to address the premium collection issue, and IRDAI noted the corrective action.
One charge, concerning differences between figures in Schedule V and intermediary-wise data, was dropped after Star Health explained that the inspection format did not provide for certain intermediary categories, including insurance marketing firms and web aggregators.
What happens next
Star Health must pay the ₹2 crore penalty by debiting its shareholders' account within 45 days of receiving the order. The insurer is also required to place the order before its board at the next meeting and submit a copy of the minutes of those deliberations to IRDAI. An Action Taken Report must be filed within 90 days.
Elets will update this story as further developments are reported.








