News · BFSI
Proposed commission caps and expense of management limits are expected to reshape competitive dynamics in Indian life insurance, with SBI Life and Canara HSBC Life among the least exposed insurers.
✦ AI SUMMARY 30-second read
- SBI Life reported the highest value of new business margin in the industry at 28.5% in the second quarter of FY27.
- Canara HSBC's expense ratio of about 18% sits close to the proposed 15% EoM threshold; a 10% cut in acquisition costs could expand its VNB margin by 2.9%.
- HDFC Life's current expense ratio of about 21% means it could mathematically reach the proposed 15% limit, while ICICI Prudential Life has already cut its cost-to-premium ratio to 18.3% in the first half of FY27.
Why it matters: Regulatory caps on commissions and management expenses could structurally shift market share toward larger, better-capitalised life insurers in India.
This summary was generated by AI. Editors may review and update it.
SBI Life Insurance and Canara HSBC Life Insurance are among the life insurers considered best positioned to benefit from proposed changes to insurance distribution regulations in India. Their relatively moderate commission ratios and controlled expense structures leave them better placed than many peers to absorb the revised framework.
The proposals under discussion include caps on commissions and limits on the expense of management. Analysts expect these measures to put greater pressure on smaller banks, brokers and corporate agents, while larger insurers with established bancassurance ties and direct agency networks may emerge stronger.
What is being proposed
The regulatory framework being consulted upon would impose EoM limits and commission caps across distribution channels. Insurers broadly support the intent of the reforms, which aim to improve distribution transparency, policyholder outcomes and product affordability.
However, companies have called for a final framework that preserves the economics of key product segments such as credit life and annuity, given their role in extending cover to underserved borrowers. Some insurers also expect the final commission limits to be less restrictive than those outlined in the consultation paper.
How individual insurers are placed
Canara HSBC Life carries an expense ratio of about 18%, compared with the proposed 15% EoM threshold. Its moderate commission rates, balanced product mix and credit life segment exposure offer some insulation. Because its bancassurance partner is also its promoter, the partner's incentive to drive sales may be preserved even if the commission structure changes. Any additional EoM headroom could allow the insurer to step up investment and growth, and a 10% reduction in acquisition costs could expand its VNB margin by 2.9%.
SBI Life reported the highest VNB margin in the industry at 28.5% in the second quarter of FY27, supported by momentum in protection products and launches in the non-participating and annuity segments, partly offset by input tax credit losses. Its distribution strength is seen as an advantage as the industry recalibrates.
HDFC Life, with a current expense ratio of about 21%, could mathematically reach the 15% EoM threshold under the proposals. The insurer expects its agency channel to be the least affected, followed by banks, with brokers and corporate agents facing relatively higher impact. ICICI Prudential Life has already reduced its cost-to-premium ratio, excluding GST, to 18.3% in the first half of FY27. Max Life expects to achieve a 5-7% reduction in its EoM ratio through commission and GST optimisation, plus a further 2-3% improvement through operating efficiencies; more than 90% of its business is expected to remain unaffected. LIC expects the changes to create opportunities for better engagement with existing distribution partners.
Industry outlook
Despite preparedness among large players, the impact on business volumes could be significant. Lower distribution costs are expected to improve product-level profitability, but volumes may face pressure in the medium term, particularly in credit life.
Individual annualised premium equivalent growth moderated in the second quarter of FY27, partly due to volatile equity markets weighing on unit-linked insurance plan demand. October growth remained subdued, with the industry recording single-digit growth. A recovery towards a sustainable mid-teen trajectory is expected, supported by a revival in ULIPs, sustained protection demand and improving guaranteed savings demand.
Insurers are increasingly investing in technology, digitisation and artificial intelligence-led productivity to manage a lower-cost distribution environment. The industry is also preparing for the transition to International Financial Reporting Standards and a risk-based solvency framework, which could improve transparency and capital allocation.
What happens next
The final shape of the commission and EoM regulations will determine the extent of competitive realignment. Most large insurers believe their current cost structures give them sufficient flexibility, though the outcome will depend heavily on channel and product mix.
Elets will continue to follow developments on insurance distribution regulation as the consultation process advances.








