News · BFSI
The Delhi High Court has held that mutual fund unit holders cannot be equated with shareholders of companies the fund invests in, with significant implications for how capital gains are taxed under the India-Mauritius tax treaty.
✦ AI SUMMARY 30-second read
- A division bench of the Delhi High Court ruled that mutual fund units and equity shares are distinct forms of investment and cannot be treated as identical.
- The court held that capital gains from the sale of mutual fund units fall under Article 13(4) of the India-Mauritius DTAA and are taxable only in Mauritius.
- The ruling relied in part on a Supreme Court precedent holding that units of the Unit Trust of India cannot be considered shares.
Why it matters: The ruling clarifies treaty taxation of mutual fund gains for Mauritius-based investors and limits the tax department's ability to equate fund units with equity shares.
This summary was generated by AI. Editors may review and update it.
The Delhi High Court has ruled that a mutual fund unit holder is not a shareholder of the companies in which the fund invests, and therefore does not carry the rights or liabilities that come with shareholding. The judgment was delivered by a division bench comprising Justice Subramonium Prasad and Justice Renu Bhatnagar.
The court stated clearly that mutual fund units and equity shares represent different forms of investment and cannot be treated as identical simply because a fund's underlying assets include equity shares.
What the court decided
The bench observed that a unit holder holds only an interest in a fund that in turn invests in shares or other securities. The unit holder has no direct rights or liabilities as a shareholder of the investee company.
Referring to the definition of a mutual fund under Securities and Exchange Board of India norms, the court noted that mutual funds are constituted as trusts that raise money by issuing units and deploy those funds in securities and other assets. This structure, the bench held, is fundamentally different from direct equity ownership.
The tax treaty dispute
The central question before the court was whether capital gains from the sale of equity-oriented mutual fund units could be taxed in India under Article 13(3A) of the India-Mauritius Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement, which covers gains from the transfer of shares.
The tax department argued that because equity-oriented mutual funds invest primarily in equity shares, their units should be treated on a par with shares for the purposes of that provision. The court rejected this position.
The bench held that such capital gains are instead governed by Article 13(4) of the India-Mauritius DTAA and are taxable only in Mauritius.
Precedent relied upon
In reaching its conclusion, the court placed reliance on the Supreme Court's ruling in Apollo Tyres Ltd. v. CIT, in which the apex court had held that units of the Unit Trust of India cannot be considered shares.
The Delhi High Court applied that reasoning to the present dispute, reinforcing the legal distinction between holding units in a fund and directly holding shares in a company.
What happens next
The ruling sets out a clear interpretive position on how mutual fund units are to be treated under India's tax treaty framework, though the tax department may consider whether to appeal the decision.
Elets will update this story as developments unfold.








